VIC GP recommendation used to justify child support?

[sammy01]

ok so csa need to determine if a change would be 'just and equitable'.
I reckon let's for a minute pretend that the health concerns justify a change. Calm down... The next step, 'just and equitable'? She doesn't work? Doesn't have a mortgage? Hmm. I'm guessing this is because of asset division at time of separation? mate, you ought to be applying for a change based on her capacity to work, but refusal to do so....

 

[Rod]

The GP letter seems off, and I'd like to know whether I'm justified in taking issue/complaint with their making recommendations about children's care arrangements? Is that in their professional boundary?

I'd be making a complaint to AHPRA about the Doctor providing advice beyond their qualifications (unless they also have psychology degree).

You want this report ruled out as beyond the scope of a GP to recommend.

 

[MP78]

Thanks Rod
We've lodged a complaint to both the GP practice manager, and AHPRA. Have asked for a written retraction for inclusion in the CSA response.

 

[Riggsle]

anyone has experienced a change in their child support assessment based on medical recommendations? Did you challenge it, and if so, what was the process like? Also, would a second medical opinion make any difference in situations like this? It seems like there could be a lot of room for interpretation when it comes to medical advice affecting financial matters.

 

[LostEcho]

If you need a second opinion from a different GP or want to discuss medical concerns that might impact child support matters, nextclinic.com.au could be a good option. Sometimes, another medical perspective can either support or challenge the claims being made. If the current recommendation is affecting financial decisions, having more medical input could help clarify things and provide a stronger case when dealing with child support issues.